4.3 KiB
How to Make a Proposal
This is a tutorial on making an effective proposal to change co-op policy. The proposal process is used for any policy or budgetary change that affects the whole cooperative.
First, read the Charter — it is what officially governs this process. What follows are some best practices to help you from there.
Is a proposal necessary?
Consider whether you really need a proposal to achieve your goal. Does your goal affect the whole community, or just you? Does it require a policy change or resources, or is it something you and a few other members could simply do?
As a community committed to self-governance and autonomy, we encourage members to take initiative on things they care about. Rules and policies are a minimal framework to support that — as much as possible, the co-op should run without needing new policies.
Sometimes what starts as a proposal is handled by a conversation that turns into collaboration and action. Consider that a victory!
Is there a working group for it already?
Before going further, check whether a working group or role is already responsible for your idea. If one exists, talk to them first: they may be able to act on it directly, and even if you do proceed, the relevant working group should have been consulted. Strong buy-in from anyone affected makes the rest easy.
Start an open thread
When you have buy-in (or want to challenge something a working group is doing), start a thread in the co-op forum:
- Title: something specific that invites an open conversation — "Should we change paragraph 3 of the charter?" rather than "Governance".
- Context: a couple of paragraphs on why you are raising this, the broader situation, any direction you lean toward, and the open questions in your mind. Raise them honestly.
Then let the thread run. Hopefully other members join in. If nobody does, that is useful information too — the idea may not have the support you hoped for, and it is better to learn that in a thread than in a vote.
The process might end here. Maybe the discussion gave you or a working group enough to act on without a formal proposal. If so, post updates on the thread about what you and other members did with the ideas. That is the process working, not failing.
Make your formal proposal
When clear consensus is forming, use the Start Poll tool in your thread and choose the co-op's proposal template. Title it starting with "Proposal:" so everyone can see what it is, and notify "Inference Cooperative," which should reach all members.
In the context, set out clearly what you are proposing to change and why — and say who will implement it. All the better if you're able to be part of implementing it yourself.
Follow the charter's standards so the poll is structured correctly:
- Keep it open for 7 days for a policy change. If something is genuinely urgent, say so plainly in the context — 7 days is still preferred in almost every case.
- Include the default Agree / Abstain / Disagree options, plus a Block option (a reasoned objection that the proposal would seriously harm the co-op).
The guidelines are slightly different for changes to the Charter.
Amendments
Members may suggest things during voting that weren't considered earlier. You may make small revisions to the proposal text while voting is open, as long as you clearly mark what changed and when. If a suggested change would so transform the proposal that someone who voted for the original might now object, close that proposal and start a fresh one.
Resolution
When the 7 days are up, announce the outcome in the thread. Under the charter:
- A policy proposal passes with at least 60% support of voting members.
- If a block was raised, it needs 75% support.
- A proposal that doesn't pass can be revised based on the feedback and started again — that is encouraged, not embarrassing.
In the outcome, explain how the proposal will be put into effect, and by whom.
Implement it
Our co-op depends on member participation. Get it done, and keep the thread updated on your progress. Good work!
Adapted from the social.coop wiki guide "Make a proposal" (CC BY-SA). We offer this under the same license.