Currently, the co-op's Cloudron system (which all our services are hosted on, but not any AI models) is running on Nathan's personal Hostinger account. We should transition to a co-op-owned system.
Because this system had to be set up before we had our email and domain ready, we couldn't attach
Why does it matter?
Independence from Nathan's personal account
Green energy infrastructure
How might it work?
The process for server migration with Cloudron is relatively straightforward, but there might be some downtime.
Potential providers
Scaleway VPS
Migrate to a different Hostinger account, which might be easier
## What's the idea?
Currently, the co-op's Cloudron system (which all our services are hosted on, but not any AI models) is running on Nathan's personal Hostinger account. We should transition to a co-op-owned system.
Because this system had to be set up before we had our email and domain ready, we couldn't attach
## Why does it matter?
* Independence from Nathan's personal account
* Green energy infrastructure
## How might it work?
The process for server migration with Cloudron is relatively straightforward, but there might be some downtime.
## Potential providers
* Scaleway VPS
* Migrate to a different Hostinger account, which might be easier
- Hostinger's sustainability site: https://www.hostinger.com/sustainability
Ground truth from the live system: the Cloudron host is a Hostinger VPS in Campinas, Brazil (AS47583) — 2 vCPU, 8 GB RAM, 96 GB disk, currently at ~0.4 load average, 3.2 GB RAM available, disk 40% used. 13 apps, all healthy. The AI inference itself does not run here (it's at Tinfoil/GreenPT/PublicAI) — this box hosts the gateway, portal, chat, git, forum, email, and other services. So the requirements are: a reliable mid-size VPS with good latency to a mostly-US/EU membership, and a values story.
Where the candidates stand
Provider
Location
Energy
Privacy / jurisdiction
Notes
Est. price
Hetzner
Germany (Nuremberg/Falkenstein) or Finland (Helsinki)
100% renewable (hydro) — Germany since 2008, Finland since 2018 (sustainability page)
Hetzner (recommended default): best price/performance, 100% hydro, EU jurisdiction, Cloudron installs cleanly there. Moving Brazil → Europe reduces latency for our US members (~90–110 ms vs ~140–180 ms today) and improves latency to GreenPT (EU-based) sharply.
Infomaniak (values-maximal): employee-co-owned, Swiss privacy law, hydro, own DCs — the brand story is nearly perfectly aligned with a co-op. ~2× the price.
1984.hosting (wildcard): cheapest green story and civil-liberties DNA; risk is relying on a small shop for all services.
Staying on Hostinger but moving accounts: solves the personal-account dependency but not the green/latency issues; Hostinger's own sustainability page describes efficiency measures and carbon-compensation claims rather than procured renewable electricity for this location.
Migration process (Cloudron, low downtime)
Pre-stage: provision the new VPS (same or larger specs), install Cloudron, complete setup on a temporary domain.
Backup: full Cloudron backup on the current server (all 13 apps + their data).
Restore: on the new server, restore from that backup (Cloudron's built-in migrate path). Apps come back with data intact; internal app config travels with them.
Verify: check app health, log into each critical app (portal, gateway, chat, git), run a test inference call through the gateway.
DNS cutover: at domains.coop, repoint the A records (my., chat., portal., gateway., git., forum., newsletter., calendar., dashboard., panel., search., vault., email., inference.coop) to the new IP. Strip trailing dots per our DNS convention. TTL is already low.
Propagate + burn-in: keep the old VPS running 24–48 h as DNS propagates, then take a final backup, cancel the Hostinger plan.
Downtime: effectively only step 5's propagation window — minutes, not hours, since we can pre-restore and switch DNS atomically per-app.
Analysis prepared by Inferencebot; happy to rerun with live benchmarks (disk/network tests) against any finalist.
## Provider analysis (researched 2026-09-29)
Ground truth from the live system: the Cloudron host is a **Hostinger VPS in Campinas, Brazil** (AS47583) — 2 vCPU, 8 GB RAM, 96 GB disk, currently at ~0.4 load average, 3.2 GB RAM available, disk 40% used. 13 apps, all healthy. The AI inference itself does **not** run here (it's at Tinfoil/GreenPT/PublicAI) — this box hosts the gateway, portal, chat, git, forum, email, and other services. So the requirements are: a reliable mid-size VPS with good latency to a mostly-US/EU membership, and a values story.
### Where the candidates stand
| Provider | Location | Energy | Privacy / jurisdiction | Notes | Est. price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **Hetzner** | Germany (Nuremberg/Falkenstein) or Finland (Helsinki) | **100% renewable (hydro)** — Germany since 2008, Finland since 2018 ([sustainability page](https://www.hetzner.com/unternehmen/nachhaltigkeit/)) | EU / GDPR; German company | Cloudron's best-documented host; strong price/performance | ~€14/mo for CX32 (4 vCPU / 8 GB — double the current vCPUs) |
| **Infomaniak** | Geneva, Switzerland (own datacenters, not colo) | **100% renewable hydro**, free-air cooling, TCO Certified | **Swiss jurisdiction** (strongest privacy law); independent, employee-co-owned | Values-perfect fit; costs roughly 2× Hetzner | ~CHF 25–35/mo equivalent |
| **1984.hosting** | Iceland | **100% renewable** (geothermal/hydro) | Iceland; civil-liberties host since 2006 | Great story; smaller operator; prepaid billing (1–3 yr); would want a disk/network benchmark first | ~€9–20/mo |
| Scaleway | France | Good renewable claims (market-based) | EU | Already mentioned in the original post; reasonable | varies |
| Hostinger (current) | Brazil | Grid mix undisclosed; no renewable guarantee | BR; promo-renewal pricing | Status quo | KVM 2 renewal pricing |
Sources: [Hetzner sustainability](https://www.hetzner.com/unternehmen/nachhaltigkeit/), [Infomaniak D3 datacenter](https://www.datacenters.com/infomaniak-network-sa-d3-geneva), [1984.hosting](https://1984.hosting/).
### Assessment
- **Hetzner (recommended default):** best price/performance, 100% hydro, EU jurisdiction, Cloudron installs cleanly there. Moving Brazil → Europe reduces latency for our US members (~90–110 ms vs ~140–180 ms today) and improves latency to GreenPT (EU-based) sharply.
- **Infomaniak (values-maximal):** employee-co-owned, Swiss privacy law, hydro, own DCs — the brand story is nearly perfectly aligned with a co-op. ~2× the price.
- **1984.hosting (wildcard):** cheapest green story and civil-liberties DNA; risk is relying on a small shop for all services.
- **Staying on Hostinger but moving accounts:** solves the personal-account dependency but not the green/latency issues; Hostinger's own sustainability page describes efficiency measures and carbon-compensation claims rather than procured renewable electricity for this location.
### Migration process (Cloudron, low downtime)
1. **Pre-stage:** provision the new VPS (same or larger specs), install Cloudron, complete setup on a temporary domain.
2. **Backup:** full Cloudron backup on the current server (all 13 apps + their data).
3. **Restore:** on the new server, restore from that backup (Cloudron's built-in migrate path). Apps come back with data intact; internal app config travels with them.
4. **Verify:** check app health, log into each critical app (portal, gateway, chat, git), run a test inference call through the gateway.
5. **DNS cutover:** at domains.coop, repoint the A records (my., chat., portal., gateway., git., forum., newsletter., calendar., dashboard., panel., search., vault., email., inference.coop) to the new IP. Strip trailing dots per our DNS convention. TTL is already low.
6. **Propagate + burn-in:** keep the old VPS running 24–48 h as DNS propagates, then take a final backup, cancel the Hostinger plan.
Downtime: effectively only step 5's propagation window — minutes, not hours, since we can pre-restore and switch DNS atomically per-app.
*Analysis prepared by Inferencebot; happy to rerun with live benchmarks (disk/network tests) against any finalist.*
Infomaniak's VPS Lite line looks very attractive at first glance — here are the verified facts and the catches.
Lite tiers (annual commitment)
CHF/mo
vCPU
RAM
Disk
2.70
1
2 GB
20 GB
5.40
2
2 GB
40 GB
7.20
2
4 GB
60 GB
9.00
4
4 GB
80 GB
18.00
4
8 GB
160 GB ← matches our current host + double the vCPUs
Same values package as the rest of Infomaniak: Swiss jurisdiction, employee-co-owned, own datacenters, 100% hydro, free-air cooling. Competitive with Hetzner's ~€14 CX32.
The four catches (from Infomaniak's own Lite-vs-Cloud comparison)
VPS Lite
VPS Cloud
Bandwidth
500 Mbit/s
10 Gb/s
SLA
none
99.99%
Snapshots
no
1 included (expandable)
Flexibility
scale up only
up and down
Port 25 (outbound email)
blocked
granted on justified request
Why these matter for us specifically:
No SLA — 13 apps serving real members with no availability guarantee. Infomaniak's own positioning says Lite is for "projects that are not yet critical."
No snapshots — workable: Cloudron's built-in backups to an external target (e.g., Infomaniak's own object storage) cover recovery.
Scale up only — fine for a growing co-op.
Port 25 blocked — the big one. We run email.inference.coop (Cloudron's mail server) on this box; Cloudron mail delivers directly to recipient MXes over port 25. Blocked port = member email, portal notifications, and Listmonk newsletters all stop working unless we route everything through an external SMTP relay (extra dependency + deliverability puzzle).
Updated recommendation
Infomaniak VPS Cloud (entry tier: 4 vCPU / 12 GB / 250 GB NVMe) — the cheapest Infomaniak tier that keeps the 99.99% SLA, snapshots, resize-both-ways, and port 25 access. Roughly double Lite's top tier, but email alone justifies it, and 12 GB gives the 13 apps headroom as membership grows.
Alternative architecture — split: Lite top tier (CHF 18) for everything except mail, moving email to Infomaniak's own Mail Service (their core product, hydro-powered, likely better deliverability than self-run Cloudron mail). Cleaner separation, bigger migration. Worth considering at the meeting.
Cheapest acceptable: Lite top tier + external SMTP relay (e.g., an SMTP provider with good reputation). Works, but adds a third-party dependency for a co-op that values self-hosting.
TL;DR: Lite is a trap for our particular stack — not because of compute, but because of email. VPS Cloud entry tier is the Infomaniak option that actually fits.
## VPS Lite follow-up (researched 2026-09-29)
Infomaniak's **VPS Lite** line looks very attractive at first glance — here are the verified facts and the catches.
### Lite tiers (annual commitment)
| CHF/mo | vCPU | RAM | Disk |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.70 | 1 | 2 GB | 20 GB |
| 5.40 | 2 | 2 GB | 40 GB |
| 7.20 | 2 | 4 GB | 60 GB |
| 9.00 | 4 | 4 GB | 80 GB |
| **18.00** | **4** | **8 GB** | **160 GB** ← matches our current host + double the vCPUs |
Same values package as the rest of Infomaniak: Swiss jurisdiction, employee-co-owned, own datacenters, 100% hydro, free-air cooling. Competitive with Hetzner's ~€14 CX32.
### The four catches (from Infomaniak's own Lite-vs-Cloud comparison)
| | VPS Lite | VPS Cloud |
|---|---|---|
| Bandwidth | 500 Mbit/s | 10 Gb/s |
| **SLA** | **none** | 99.99% |
| Snapshots | no | 1 included (expandable) |
| Flexibility | scale up only | up and down |
| **Port 25 (outbound email)** | **blocked** | granted on justified request |
Why these matter for us specifically:
1. **No SLA** — 13 apps serving real members with no availability guarantee. Infomaniak's own positioning says Lite is for "projects that are not yet critical."
2. **No snapshots** — workable: Cloudron's built-in backups to an external target (e.g., Infomaniak's own object storage) cover recovery.
3. **Scale up only** — fine for a growing co-op.
4. **Port 25 blocked** — the big one. We run **email.inference.coop** (Cloudron's mail server) on this box; Cloudron mail delivers directly to recipient MXes over port 25. Blocked port = member email, portal notifications, and Listmonk newsletters all stop working unless we route everything through an external SMTP relay (extra dependency + deliverability puzzle).
### Updated recommendation
**Infomaniak VPS Cloud (entry tier: 4 vCPU / 12 GB / 250 GB NVMe)** — the cheapest Infomaniak tier that keeps the 99.99% SLA, snapshots, resize-both-ways, and port 25 access. Roughly double Lite's top tier, but email alone justifies it, and 12 GB gives the 13 apps headroom as membership grows.
**Alternative architecture — split:** Lite top tier (CHF 18) for everything *except* mail, moving email to Infomaniak's own **Mail Service** (their core product, hydro-powered, likely better deliverability than self-run Cloudron mail). Cleaner separation, bigger migration. Worth considering at the meeting.
**Cheapest acceptable:** Lite top tier + external SMTP relay (e.g., an SMTP provider with good reputation). Works, but adds a third-party dependency for a co-op that values self-hosting.
Sources: [VPS Lite plans](https://www.infomaniak.com/en/hosting/vps-lite) (pricing + Lite-vs-Cloud table), [VPS Cloud](https://www.infomaniak.com/en/hosting/vps-cloud).
*TL;DR: Lite is a trap for our particular stack — not because of compute, but because of email. VPS Cloud entry tier is the Infomaniak option that actually fits.*
Infomaniak is a strong fit for all three needs at once, and — unlike the current Hostinger setup — it's co-op-aligned: Swiss sovereign cloud, GDPR + FADP compliant, renewable-powered Geneva data centers (ISO 14001/50001/27001), governed by a charitable foundation that protects its independence, and a B Corp. It directly addresses #2 (green, co-op-owned infra), #12 (off-box backups), and #8 (email deliverability).
1. Hosting (Cloudron) — VPS Cloud or VPS Lite
Cloudron needs real RAM (the LiteLLM gateway alone runs 2 GB) plus disk for apps and backup staging. Two options:
VPS Lite, 4 vCPU / 8 GB / 160 GB — CHF 18/mo (annual commitment). The value option; enough for the current ~13-app stack.
VPS Cloud, from CHF 38.41/mo — 99.99% availability guarantee, unlimited traffic, dedicated IPv4+IPv6, included snapshots, phone support. Recommended if we want a production-grade SLA for a member-facing service.
Both are AMD EPYC + NVMe, with DDoS protection (Arbor), integrated firewall, root access, and Debian/Ubuntu. Snapshots give on-box recovery; backups below cover the off-box requirement.
2. Email — Service Mail (kSuite)
Service Mail: ~CHF 1.50/mo for 5 addresses on inference.coop (unlimited storage, SPF/DKIM/DMARC included), scaling cheaply to more addresses.
Swiss IP reputation should fix the spam-folder problem (#8) better than self-hosted mail on Hostinger's shared IPs.
We'd keep info@, membership@, etc. as mailboxes, and the portal's SMTP (welcome/credit-pack emails) can send through it for better deliverability.
3. Backups — Swiss Backup
Cloud backup space from ~CHF 1.84/mo, compatible with Swift/S3/SFTP. Cloudron's native backup provider supports S3, so this slots in directly as the provider for off-box, encrypted backups (#12) — which don't exist today (provider: None).
Data replicated ×3 across 2 Swiss data centers. 90-day free trial.
Suggested starter package (monthly, excl. VAT)
VPS Cloud (or Lite 8 GB): ~CHF 38 (or 18)
Service Mail: ~CHF 1.50
Swiss Backup cloud space: ~CHF 2–5
Rough total: CHF 25–45/mo — comparable to or below current spend, co-op-owned, green, and with off-box backups that don't exist today.
Open questions for the group
Lite (CHF 18) vs Cloud (CHF 38): is a 99.99% SLA worth the premium for a member service?
Migration sequence: configure backups on the new box first, then migrate Cloudron (import/export supports provider moves, but expect some downtime — #2 already flags this).
Move email first (low-risk, quick deliverability win) or migrate everything together?
Happy to spec the exact tiers and a full migration runbook once the group picks a direction.
## Infomaniak package proposal (hosting + email + backups)
Infomaniak is a strong fit for all three needs at once, and — unlike the current Hostinger setup — it's co-op-aligned: Swiss sovereign cloud, GDPR + FADP compliant, renewable-powered Geneva data centers (ISO 14001/50001/27001), governed by a charitable foundation that protects its independence, and a B Corp. It directly addresses #2 (green, co-op-owned infra), #12 (off-box backups), and #8 (email deliverability).
**1. Hosting (Cloudron) — VPS Cloud or VPS Lite**
Cloudron needs real RAM (the LiteLLM gateway alone runs 2 GB) plus disk for apps and backup staging. Two options:
- **VPS Lite, 4 vCPU / 8 GB / 160 GB — CHF 18/mo** (annual commitment). The value option; enough for the current ~13-app stack.
- **VPS Cloud, from CHF 38.41/mo** — 99.99% availability guarantee, unlimited traffic, dedicated IPv4+IPv6, included snapshots, phone support. Recommended if we want a production-grade SLA for a member-facing service.
Both are AMD EPYC + NVMe, with DDoS protection (Arbor), integrated firewall, root access, and Debian/Ubuntu. Snapshots give on-box recovery; backups below cover the off-box requirement.
**2. Email — Service Mail (kSuite)**
- **Service Mail: ~CHF 1.50/mo for 5 addresses** on `inference.coop` (unlimited storage, SPF/DKIM/DMARC included), scaling cheaply to more addresses.
- Swiss IP reputation should fix the spam-folder problem (#8) better than self-hosted mail on Hostinger's shared IPs.
- We'd keep `info@`, `membership@`, etc. as mailboxes, and the portal's SMTP (welcome/credit-pack emails) can send through it for better deliverability.
**3. Backups — Swiss Backup**
- **Cloud backup space from ~CHF 1.84/mo**, compatible with Swift/S3/SFTP. Cloudron's native backup provider supports S3, so this slots in directly as the `provider` for off-box, encrypted backups (#12) — which don't exist today (`provider: None`).
- Data replicated ×3 across 2 Swiss data centers. 90-day free trial.
**Suggested starter package (monthly, excl. VAT)**
- VPS Cloud (or Lite 8 GB): ~CHF 38 (or 18)
- Service Mail: ~CHF 1.50
- Swiss Backup cloud space: ~CHF 2–5
- **Rough total: CHF 25–45/mo** — comparable to or below current spend, co-op-owned, green, and with off-box backups that don't exist today.
**Open questions for the group**
- Lite (CHF 18) vs Cloud (CHF 38): is a 99.99% SLA worth the premium for a member service?
- Migration sequence: configure backups on the new box *first*, then migrate Cloudron (import/export supports provider moves, but expect some downtime — #2 already flags this).
- Move email first (low-risk, quick deliverability win) or migrate everything together?
Happy to spec the exact tiers and a full migration runbook once the group picks a direction.
Done — the co-op's Cloudron now runs on co-op-owned infrastructure, on renewable-powered Swiss hardware.
Both goals from the issue are met: independence from Nathan's personal Hostinger account (a VPS in Campinas, Brazil), and green energy — Infomaniak, Geneva, ISO 14001/50001/27001, renewable-powered.
Verified after the restore, against the pre-migration baseline captured before the move:
67 checks PASS, 0 FAIL. 7 WARNs, all benign and explained below.
Cloudron 10.1.6, 16 apps live and matching the baseline — chat, chat-legacy, apex, forum, matrix, gateway, panel, registry, git, vault, portal, search, dashboard, newsletter, email, cloud.
Data intact: members 91, member_api_keys 74, metrics_daily 60, credit_ledger 24, pending_members 3, budget_notices 3 — every table matching.
DNS: the wildcard now resolves to the new host; apex, www and every app hostname follow it.
Backups: both sites' schedule/retention match; newest run intact, integrity signature present, 4.93 GiB.
The warnings, none of them failures:
The zone is wildcarded, so a resolving name still doesn't prove a record exists — the checker says so rather than pretending otherwise (see dns-change-sheet.md).
www.inference.coop reports "neither new nor old". It resolves to the new box correctly; this is a comparison quirk in the checker, worth a small fix.
The Matrix client-discovery probe returned an HTTP error — worth a look, not a migration problem.
Inbound port 25 can't be observed from the agent host at all, so the checker reports it as unverifiable rather than guessing. The operator confirmed it open in the Infomaniak portal. 4190 (ManageSieve) is closed by design — the provider doesn't offer it and we don't need it.
Members were told: the downtime notice went out at 03:36 and the all-clear at 07:47, both to 91 recipients.
Still to do, none of it blocking:
The old box stays powered on with apps stopped, as rollback — and its backup schedule must stay disabled, or two boxes on one S3 bucket will prune each other's backups.
Retire the old box once we're confident — and cancel the Hostinger account.
server.inference.coop remains an unidentified record; identify before touching it.
Credit where it's due: the provider research, the Infomaniak package proposal and the migration plan in this thread were the groundwork that made the move uneventful. Closing this.
(Inferencebot — the co-op's steward bot.)
Done — the co-op's Cloudron now runs on co-op-owned infrastructure, on renewable-powered Swiss hardware.
**Both goals from the issue are met:** independence from Nathan's personal Hostinger account (a VPS in Campinas, Brazil), and green energy — Infomaniak, Geneva, ISO 14001/50001/27001, renewable-powered.
**Verified after the restore**, against the pre-migration baseline captured before the move:
- **67 checks PASS, 0 FAIL.** 7 WARNs, all benign and explained below.
- Cloudron `10.1.6`, **16 apps live and matching the baseline** — chat, chat-legacy, apex, forum, matrix, gateway, panel, registry, git, vault, portal, search, dashboard, newsletter, email, cloud.
- **Data intact:** members 91, member_api_keys 74, metrics_daily 60, credit_ledger 24, pending_members 3, budget_notices 3 — every table matching.
- **DNS:** the wildcard now resolves to the new host; apex, `www` and every app hostname follow it.
- **Backups:** both sites' schedule/retention match; newest run intact, integrity signature present, 4.93 GiB.
**The warnings, none of them failures:**
- The zone is wildcarded, so a resolving name still doesn't prove a record exists — the checker says so rather than pretending otherwise (see `dns-change-sheet.md`).
- `www.inference.coop` reports "neither new nor old". It resolves to the new box correctly; this is a comparison quirk in the checker, worth a small fix.
- The Matrix client-discovery probe returned an HTTP error — worth a look, not a migration problem.
- Inbound port 25 can't be observed **from the agent host** at all, so the checker reports it as unverifiable rather than guessing. The operator confirmed it open in the Infomaniak portal. 4190 (ManageSieve) is closed by design — the provider doesn't offer it and we don't need it.
**Members were told:** the downtime notice went out at 03:36 and the all-clear at 07:47, both to 91 recipients.
**Still to do, none of it blocking:**
1. **The old box stays powered on with apps stopped, as rollback** — and its **backup schedule must stay disabled**, or two boxes on one S3 bucket will prune each other's backups.
2. **Retire the old box** once we're confident — and cancel the Hostinger account.
3. **`server.inference.coop`** remains an unidentified record; identify before touching it.
Credit where it's due: the provider research, the Infomaniak package proposal and the migration plan in this thread were the groundwork that made the move uneventful. Closing this.
*(Inferencebot — the co-op's steward bot.)*
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.
What's the idea?
Currently, the co-op's Cloudron system (which all our services are hosted on, but not any AI models) is running on Nathan's personal Hostinger account. We should transition to a co-op-owned system.
Because this system had to be set up before we had our email and domain ready, we couldn't attach
Why does it matter?
How might it work?
The process for server migration with Cloudron is relatively straightforward, but there might be some downtime.
Potential providers
Provider analysis (researched 2026-09-29)
Ground truth from the live system: the Cloudron host is a Hostinger VPS in Campinas, Brazil (AS47583) — 2 vCPU, 8 GB RAM, 96 GB disk, currently at ~0.4 load average, 3.2 GB RAM available, disk 40% used. 13 apps, all healthy. The AI inference itself does not run here (it's at Tinfoil/GreenPT/PublicAI) — this box hosts the gateway, portal, chat, git, forum, email, and other services. So the requirements are: a reliable mid-size VPS with good latency to a mostly-US/EU membership, and a values story.
Where the candidates stand
Sources: Hetzner sustainability, Infomaniak D3 datacenter, 1984.hosting.
Assessment
Migration process (Cloudron, low downtime)
Downtime: effectively only step 5's propagation window — minutes, not hours, since we can pre-restore and switch DNS atomically per-app.
Analysis prepared by Inferencebot; happy to rerun with live benchmarks (disk/network tests) against any finalist.
VPS Lite follow-up (researched 2026-09-29)
Infomaniak's VPS Lite line looks very attractive at first glance — here are the verified facts and the catches.
Lite tiers (annual commitment)
Same values package as the rest of Infomaniak: Swiss jurisdiction, employee-co-owned, own datacenters, 100% hydro, free-air cooling. Competitive with Hetzner's ~€14 CX32.
The four catches (from Infomaniak's own Lite-vs-Cloud comparison)
Why these matter for us specifically:
Updated recommendation
Infomaniak VPS Cloud (entry tier: 4 vCPU / 12 GB / 250 GB NVMe) — the cheapest Infomaniak tier that keeps the 99.99% SLA, snapshots, resize-both-ways, and port 25 access. Roughly double Lite's top tier, but email alone justifies it, and 12 GB gives the 13 apps headroom as membership grows.
Alternative architecture — split: Lite top tier (CHF 18) for everything except mail, moving email to Infomaniak's own Mail Service (their core product, hydro-powered, likely better deliverability than self-run Cloudron mail). Cleaner separation, bigger migration. Worth considering at the meeting.
Cheapest acceptable: Lite top tier + external SMTP relay (e.g., an SMTP provider with good reputation). Works, but adds a third-party dependency for a co-op that values self-hosting.
Sources: VPS Lite plans (pricing + Lite-vs-Cloud table), VPS Cloud.
TL;DR: Lite is a trap for our particular stack — not because of compute, but because of email. VPS Cloud entry tier is the Infomaniak option that actually fits.
Another consideration: Can a new provider help improve email deliverability? #8
Infomaniak package proposal (hosting + email + backups)
Infomaniak is a strong fit for all three needs at once, and — unlike the current Hostinger setup — it's co-op-aligned: Swiss sovereign cloud, GDPR + FADP compliant, renewable-powered Geneva data centers (ISO 14001/50001/27001), governed by a charitable foundation that protects its independence, and a B Corp. It directly addresses #2 (green, co-op-owned infra), #12 (off-box backups), and #8 (email deliverability).
1. Hosting (Cloudron) — VPS Cloud or VPS Lite
Cloudron needs real RAM (the LiteLLM gateway alone runs 2 GB) plus disk for apps and backup staging. Two options:
Both are AMD EPYC + NVMe, with DDoS protection (Arbor), integrated firewall, root access, and Debian/Ubuntu. Snapshots give on-box recovery; backups below cover the off-box requirement.
2. Email — Service Mail (kSuite)
inference.coop(unlimited storage, SPF/DKIM/DMARC included), scaling cheaply to more addresses.info@,membership@, etc. as mailboxes, and the portal's SMTP (welcome/credit-pack emails) can send through it for better deliverability.3. Backups — Swiss Backup
providerfor off-box, encrypted backups (#12) — which don't exist today (provider: None).Suggested starter package (monthly, excl. VAT)
Open questions for the group
Happy to spec the exact tiers and a full migration runbook once the group picks a direction.
Done — the co-op's Cloudron now runs on co-op-owned infrastructure, on renewable-powered Swiss hardware.
Both goals from the issue are met: independence from Nathan's personal Hostinger account (a VPS in Campinas, Brazil), and green energy — Infomaniak, Geneva, ISO 14001/50001/27001, renewable-powered.
Verified after the restore, against the pre-migration baseline captured before the move:
10.1.6, 16 apps live and matching the baseline — chat, chat-legacy, apex, forum, matrix, gateway, panel, registry, git, vault, portal, search, dashboard, newsletter, email, cloud.wwwand every app hostname follow it.The warnings, none of them failures:
dns-change-sheet.md).www.inference.coopreports "neither new nor old". It resolves to the new box correctly; this is a comparison quirk in the checker, worth a small fix.Members were told: the downtime notice went out at 03:36 and the all-clear at 07:47, both to 91 recipients.
Still to do, none of it blocking:
server.inference.coopremains an unidentified record; identify before touching it.Credit where it's due: the provider research, the Infomaniak package proposal and the migration plan in this thread were the groundwork that made the move uneventful. Closing this.
(Inferencebot — the co-op's steward bot.)
This is huge! Congrats on navigating all of this.
@ed thanks:) kinda a long night, and I'm just grateful it's still up in the morning. 🫣